Bucks dropping antlers now??
Bucks dropping antlers now??
We have had some strange activity lately... Been finding sheds over the last 2 weeks... Not that odd, but still makes you say "hmm"... Then on Friday, one hunter sees a buck with one antler... again, not that strange, "I guess hes been fighting". But then, for the grand finale, on Saturday, a hunter shot a "huge doe" then when he walked up to it it was actually a buck that had dropped both antlers. Is this strange? I have never noticed the deer dropping their antlers this early. I am curious about yalls experience.
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
It is pretty common actually. I can remember this type of stuff happening for the last ten years.
Peewee
-
- Duck South Addict
- Posts: 2147
- Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2008 10:37 am
- Location: Madison by way of Quitman County
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
Never understood why people shoot does past Christmas. We take all of our does between Oct. 1 and November 24 and we try to harvest all of them with our bows. by shooting them this late, you are taking away your future deer herd if the does have already been bred. I guess not everyone is managing their deer herd like we try to though.
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
I don't see where it hurts to kill them now. Same end result as shooting them early. Either way you are taking a doe that should have a fawn. All I can see is wasted buck effort and I'm sure he doesn't mind;)
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
Yes we try to shoot as many as we can before Christmas. And only shoot 4 1/2 year old bucks or older. 10 days ago we took a picture of 26 deer in a plot. That group consisted of 25 does and one buck. for us, the "dont kill does after Christmas" plan doesn't cover our needs. We can certainly spare more does, even if they're pregnant. We would actually need to shoot em year round to keep them in check. It was unfortunate to kill a buck and the hunter was devastated. We have never seen them drop this early so it was a big surprise. Hence the reason for this post regarding early antler shedding. I found this article on QDMA. Very informative. We are in the delta and have been largely flooded since Christmas so it makes more sense now.
http://www.qdma.com/articles/causes-of- ... er-casting
http://www.qdma.com/articles/causes-of- ... er-casting
-
- Duck South Addict
- Posts: 2147
- Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2008 10:37 am
- Location: Madison by way of Quitman County
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
have bow, will travelmrducks wrote:Yes we try to shoot as many as we can before Christmas. And only shoot 4 1/2 year old bucks or older. 10 days ago we took a picture of 26 deer in a plot. That group consisted of 25 does and one buck. for us, the "dont kill does after Christmas" plan doesn't cover our needs. We can certainly spare more does, even if they're pregnant. We would actually need to shoot em year round to keep them in check. It was unfortunate to kill a buck and the hunter was devastated. We have never seen them drop this early so it was a big surprise. Hence the reason for this post regarding early antler shedding. I found this article on QDMA. Very informative. We are in the delta and have been largely flooded since Christmas so it makes more sense now.
http://www.qdma.com/articles/causes-of- ... er-casting

Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
Definite advantages to shooting your does early so that you do not mistake a buck with no antlers or a toe head for a good sized doe. On the other hand, nothing wrong with removing deer from the herd, even a future deer from the herd, if your #s are already too high. You have not managed your deer herd any different by shooting that soon to be bred doe on Thanksgiving as you are if you shoot her on January 1. You removed that deer and any offspring that deer would have in the future no matter when the date of death is. Explain if I am missing something?huntersmky wrote:Never understood why people shoot does past Christmas. We take all of our does between Oct. 1 and November 24 and we try to harvest all of them with our bows. by shooting them this late, you are taking away your future deer herd if the does have already been bred. I guess not everyone is managing their deer herd like we try to though.
Are we gonna get wet?
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
Nope SWAG, you nailed it. Besides acccidentally shooting a buck, I have never understood why people who are wanting to thin does stop at Christmas.
-
- Veteran
- Posts: 186
- Joined: Wed Jul 28, 2010 1:14 pm
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
Same boat your in MRDUCKS. I too like to shoot ours early, but we have to shoot them early and often to keep numbers in check. I had a buddy shoot "a huge doe" Sat afternoon that turned out to be a 3 and 1/2 year old buck that had already shed. Disappointing to say the least. We might just up the doe killing even more for early season.
-
- Duck South Addict
- Posts: 2147
- Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2008 10:37 am
- Location: Madison by way of Quitman County
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
what if she's carrying the next booner on your property? you will never know. I'd rather shoot them before they are bred and start over next year with thinning the deer that haven't been bred and are does. I guess it's all in what each person wants for their place.SWAG wrote:Definite advantages to shooting your does early so that you do not mistake a buck with no antlers or a toe head for a good sized doe. On the other hand, nothing wrong with removing deer from the herd, even a future deer from the herd, if your #s are already too high. You have not managed your deer herd any different by shooting that soon to be bred doe on Thanksgiving as you are if you shoot her on January 1. You removed that deer and any offspring that deer would have in the future no matter when the date of death is. Explain if I am missing something?huntersmky wrote:Never understood why people shoot does past Christmas. We take all of our does between Oct. 1 and November 24 and we try to harvest all of them with our bows. by shooting them this late, you are taking away your future deer herd if the does have already been bred. I guess not everyone is managing their deer herd like we try to though.
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
huntersmky wrote:SWAG wrote:huntersmky wrote:Never understood why people shoot does past Christmas. We take all of our does between Oct. 1 and
what if she's carrying the next booner on your property? you will never know. I'd rather shoot them before they are bred and start over next year with thinning the deer that haven't been bred and are does. I guess it's all in what each person wants for their place.
Why is it different from taking out a doe early that "may" have been bred and carried a booner? There is none. Either way there will be no offspring.
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
What if she WAS going to be carrying a Booner and you shot her in October.huntersmky wrote:what if she's carrying the next booner on your property? you will never know. I'd rather shoot them before they are bred and start over next year with thinning the deer that haven't been bred and are does. I guess it's all in what each person wants for their place.SWAG wrote:Definite advantages to shooting your does early so that you do not mistake a buck with no antlers or a toe head for a good sized doe. On the other hand, nothing wrong with removing deer from the herd, even a future deer from the herd, if your #s are already too high. You have not managed your deer herd any different by shooting that soon to be bred doe on Thanksgiving as you are if you shoot her on January 1. You removed that deer and any offspring that deer would have in the future no matter when the date of death is. Explain if I am missing something?huntersmky wrote:Never understood why people shoot does past Christmas. We take all of our does between Oct. 1 and November 24 and we try to harvest all of them with our bows. by shooting them this late, you are taking away your future deer herd if the does have already been bred. I guess not everyone is managing their deer herd like we try to though.
Are we gonna get wet?
- msbigdawg1234
- Duck South Addict
- Posts: 5145
- Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 9:07 pm
- Location: Vicksburg
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
I see both sides dead is dead... But I don't shoot them late cause ya never know they maybe late in cycle and be hot and that booner looking for that last hot one is behind her somewhere
My name is Rick Daughtry.......
Well, I had a lot of money, but to the city went
I met too many good looking girls and that's where my money went
Yeah I know just where it went
No I ain't broke but I'm badly bent.
Well, I had a lot of money, but to the city went
I met too many good looking girls and that's where my money went
Yeah I know just where it went
No I ain't broke but I'm badly bent.
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
Killing them in October and November is ideal but in the southern part of the state that can be a challenge. Fawns drop so late that a lot of them will still have spots in Oct and Early November. I refuse to orphan a yearling that young. By January the yearlings will have grown a little and gotten a lot more mature. We try to shoot only maiden doe's in Oct & Nov but sometimes you need to take out one or two more in January.
Re: Bucks dropping antlers now??
That's the only good reason I've seen on this thread not to shoot a doe late in the season other than making sure you don't accidentally shoot a buck that has shed. This killing bred does thing is completely absurd.msbigdawg1234 wrote:I see both sides dead is dead... But I don't shoot them late cause ya never know they maybe late in cycle and be hot and that booner looking for that last hot one is behind her somewhere

"Well we don't rent pigs and I figure it's better to say it right out front because a man that does like to rent pigs is... he's hard to stop" -Augustus McRae
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot] and 22 guests